Wednesday, April 18, 2012
Wednesday, April 4, 2012
PRICING TO CUSTOMER EXPECTATIONS
Article in the World Economic
Journal - Nov. 2011
Written by Michael Hurwich and Julia Reshetnikva
(EDITED 2012)
Price consulting is mostly all about understanding what drives purchasing
behavior. In interviewing a thousand people we can find various commonalities.
For example some people may have similar value expectations for a product or
service. Perhaps, for some the driver is brand name, while for others it could
be price. After collecting appropriate data, we can then construct a value
proposition for people seeking brand loyalty.
Measuring the psychology of
purchasing behavior is very important. With so many competitors worldwide, it
is very important to understand how customers trade value for price.
Furthermore, a 1% change in price typically represents an 11% increase in net
revenue.
Price is a very powerful lever to
improve profitability.
STRATEGIC PRICING MANAGEMENT:
Previously, adjusting price was a
decision left to only one individual (known as a "Price Czar"). Usually
this individual works in the Finance or Accounting department. This person's
unilateral decision was basically the one adopted by the company to establish
the price. However this specific process represented an inside-out approach. In
those days, companies always looked at cost involved in producing a product or
providing a service to a customer. This traditional form of pricing involved
adding a fixed-markup to a product's cost to ensure a target margin. From here, companies traditionally went to market with
a margin markup strategy. If customers found the price unattractive, the
company would be forced to discount their products and services or fear a rapid
decline forecasted sales.
Today, most companies in well
developed countries have adopted what is commonly known as value-based pricing
strategies. This outside-in approach is more complicated but much more
effective. The price is not set from inside the company, but rather is set in learning
and understanding a customers use of products and services and their willingness
to pay for the derived benefit of the product or service. Some companies have
known to measure customer decision selection criteria and purchasing behavior
by the hour or minute to determine the price-benefit equation. This tactic is
known as dynamic pricing.
THE ROLE OF THE PRICING CONSLTANT:
Pricing consultants are typically
used today to look at the historical data of unit sales of companies by
reviewing the nature of what has been sold in the past. The process is
typically known as regression or cluster analysis and is used to
determine the nature of purchases and the consistency of pricing performance.
Past volume and prices obtained can often be used to determine future prices in
the absence of external market research. When historical data is insufficient
companies often conduct a primary field research by talking to a select group
of respondents with prior experience using a similar product to determine the
demand based on the suggested price and value proposition of the new product or
service.
Price affects everyone. There is not a company in the world
that doesn't talk about price at some point during any given day. Interestingly,
most of the focus of price consultancy firms is not around price, but rather in
understanding a company's value proposition to customers. Price is merely the
reward for creating, capturing and communicating value into the marketplace.
THE RESEARCH PROCESS (McDonalds Case Study)
McDonalds was an interesting
client, in that they asked us to review their pricing and value proposition for
the Big Mac and Happy Meal for the US market versus existing competitive
products with equivalent value propositions. In the USA the Happy Meal was
$5.99. McDonalds sought to understand if they have the right price relative to
competitors.
We [SPMG] decided to use a
customer segmentation model to understand the McDonalds customers pricing pain threshold relative to their value
proposition. There are 4 types of customer segments. Price sensitive customers segment usually representing 33% of the
marketplace. The convenience customer
is typically represented by 15% of the market, while loyalty customers represent 25% of the market. Finally the value customer segment is always looking
to measure value in relation to price.
The research for McDonalds
unveiled different price thresholds for different customer segments using diverse
delivery channels. McDonalds conducted the price research across the contiguous
United States and Canada with 1600 customers. What was interesting is that most
customers represented by 75% of the sample didn't even know the right price of
the Big Mac and Happy meal. They actually thought that it was 20% higher. The message
here: if customers fail to know the right
price, it is implied that McDonalds was leaving money on the table. If customers
didn't know the price that they suggested, there is a lot more value as perceived
by the customer than the price that was being charged. McDonalds had to rethink their price-value strategy and what to do with
their price.
There was a different price-point
threshold across different channels. Because McDonalds avoided charging
different price across their four channels we took an average of all the
channels and arrived at a new price that would be optimal for drive-through clientele
as well as for customers that dined-in.
CONCLUSION: The benefit to McDonalds was roughly $80 million
dollars to their top-line revenue merely by adjusting price to more adequately
reflect current market and competitive conditions.
PRICING EXCELLENCE
Science-based segmentation
utilizes data analysis and statistical methods to group customers into
"significantly similar" groups. The object is to create segment
optimized pricing given particular buying behaviour of that segment.
Today companies use sophisticated
pricing tools to derive price and measure the psychology of purchasing behavior
in what is an important and key attribute of price-value consulting.
Another tool used in pricing is
called Monadic testing which only
tests price in the absence of other product or service characteristics. In
Monadic testing you are attempting to test different price points. If you get a
large enough sample you can determine acceptable price points that represent
the majority of market share.
Another useful tool that is
commonly used is called Price-Value
mapping. This tool shows your company how a customer evaluates specific
product and service attributed to price. The tricky part of constructing a Price/Value Map is estimating the
product & service value to the average customer. We recommend the
identification of a handful of product or service features that your customers
care about most and then try to determine. You would plot the price and value
on a price value map. The Price-Value map is one and most important, most often
used pricing tools in the industry today.
Wednesday, March 7, 2012
Restaurant Pricing - Some "Food for Thought"
By Peter Maniscalco
My wife and I recently visited one of our favorite local restaurants (a "Bar & Grill" as it's called). We've been loyal customers for several years. It's a nice place, always busy with good food, service, atmosphere and, reasonable prices. Clientele is mixed (i.e. blue and white collar patrons)as the establishment is located in the suburbs but, not close in proximity to a major city either. Sounds like a great place so far, right? Well, that was the case until about six months ago after we had some new priced "food for thought".
What happened? Well, whether it was due to the change in economic conditions over the last few years or not, the Bar & Grill decided to make some changes. The food is still good with same portion sizes and the atmosphere is still nice, however, the grill extended the length of the bar. Okay, so they can now seat several more customers at the bar. I see the improvement. What we noticed even more was a complete change out of staff members. And yes, as a result there has been a noticeable decline in the level of quality service in addition to (are you ready for this?), selective yet significant price increases in the menu!
Examples include a two dollar increase for a salad, a one to two dollar increase for a cocktail, and a one to two dollar increase for a dessert. This all happened within a month or so of completing the bar "renovation".
Well, we all know commodity costs have increased in the last couple of years or so but did the Bar & Grill inadvertently "overlook", ignore, or just plain screw up their value proposition here? The staff, according to what we understand from an inside "source", is much less costly compared to the prior staff. All right, so now their variable costs have decreased. But, the additional costs incurred were for the extended bar, a one-time fixed cost investment! My "Food for Thought?" The food/drink price increases are significant, there is a decline in the level of quality customer service but quality of food and atmosphere are still solid. However, from what we've heard and observed, the level of business has dropped noticeably.
The key points missed here by the owner are that a value proposition contains more than just the price element; pricing is not solely just a function of costs; and to be successful one must take into consideration the target market/customer base.(i.e. segmentation)
Alternative solutions? Sure. Here are a few quick and obvious ones that the owner(s) could have taken.
- Bar & grill could have held its prices, for at least a little longer anyway. Please don't let me as a customer think your price increases are simply a way to help you cover your sunk cost investment (i.e. extending the length of the bar). Since there was an "overhaul" of the staff which reduced its variable costs, by holding its prices the Bar & Grill could probably still maintain its margins even in light of commodity cost increases. Or, an option would have been to implement smaller and selective price increases, if the owners felt compelled to do so.
- Bar & Grill could have implemented a less obvious price increase by "downsizing" the portion of its food and drinks, instead of the quite more noticeable price increases.
- Instead of a mass overhaul of its staff, the owners could have taken a selective approach in terms of reducing its variable costs. For example, the owners could review their payroll staff and re-balance their hours and schedules based on employee labor expense differences.
Will we frequent this establishment as often? Most likely not. I'm not sure where the value is now, since we(and other patrons I'm sure) observed quite noticeable price increases, an obvious decline in quality customer service and a feeling that the restaurant lost sight of the customer. Maybe the Bar & Grill will recognize that its value proposition is not(or should not be) just all about recovering its costs.
Tuesday, March 6, 2012
Upcoming Webinar: Legal Tools for Value Pricing
Particularly in difficult economic times, value pricing can be a successful means to maximize profit by pricing products and services based on their value to end-users, rather than on the supplier’s cost. Applying it necessarily means that end-users are segmented, so that some will receive better prices than others. But many companies rely on the mistaken belief that the law requires “fair and equitable” treatment of customers to create self-imposed roadblocks to effective value pricing.
Gene Zelek, an experienced pricing attorney and former marketing manager, will show how the law is fully supportive of price segmentation. He will also demonstrate how the law permits the preservation of end-user value pricing by controlling corrosive price competition among distributors, retailers and other intermediaries (including those selling over the Internet) with resale price policies and minimum advertised price (MAP) programs. Finally, Gene will discuss price signaling as a lawful way to avoid sending the wrong messages to the marketplace that jeopardize value pricing strategies.
This webinar will cover the following topics:
- How the law allows account-specific pricing for effective segmentation
- Why resale price encouragement and setting is lawful in the U.S. and Canada
- The essential elements of legally compliant price signaling
REGISTER: http://www.spmgpricing.com/Webinars.aspx
Presented by:
Eugene F. Zelek, Jr.
Partner and Chair, Antitrust & Trade Regulation Group
Freeborn & Peters LLP
Partner and Chair, Antitrust & Trade Regulation Group
Freeborn & Peters LLP
Tuesday, February 14, 2012
Canada's Airlines Move to all-in ad Pricing
Updated: Wed Feb. 08 2012 20:02:37 The Canadian Press
MONTREAL — Canada's largest airlines have all launched all-inclusive pricing efforts that make it easier for passengers to determine the actual cost of flying. Air Canada began on Wednesday to advertise prices that show the final cost of a ticket by combining the extra charges that have been left out in the past. Porter Airlines, which flies regional planes mainly from its base at Toronto City Centre airport said it would begin to advertise the total cost of a flight on Friday.
They join WestJet Airlines (TSX:WJA) which began to advertise all-in fares in January.
The new pricing structure will factor in all of the fees, surcharges and taxes that customers wind up paying, which in some cases can virtually double the posted price of airline tickets.
The extra amounts include Nav Canada fees, airport improvement charges, fuel surcharges, insurance and air security charges.
Consumers also have to add taxes -- GST or Harmonized Sales Tax, and possibly sales tax or other taxes depending on the province or country. Canada's largest carrier (TSX:AC.B) launched its new all-in fare policy as it unveiled a seat sale marking its 75th anniversary. "Our all-in price advertising initiative is a response to our customers' increased desire for transparency and simplicity when shopping for air fares," said Air Canada marketing vice-president Craig Landry.
Air Canada's new all-in price will be displayed on its website, email specials, online and print advertising. Large newspaper ads on Wednesday, for example, showed a flight from Montreal to London costing $887, with the base fare starting at $244 and $643 in additional charges. Final prices may vary by routing and individual options such as baggage fees.
The changes come ahead of laws requiring more honest airfare ads expected later this year. Robert Kokonis, president of airline consulting firm AirTrav Inc., said the carriers didn't want to wait until the Christmas deadline. "I think they wanted to get it over with and also position themselves in front of the consumers' eyes as doing the right thing," he said in an interview. Calgary-based WestJet changed its print advertising in January, but bookings on its website and that of Air Canada don't at first glance show all-in prices.
"We are still working out some technical details to be able to display all-in pricing within our booking engine, which we expect will happen later this year," said spokesman Robert Palmer. Passengers initially see only the base fare when choosing flight times. But they can see the all-in price and breakdown of extra charges by clicking the price associated with individual flights. Unlike the other carriers, Porter will only show one price without highlighting fees and taxes separately, said president Robert Deluce. "We've been able to change what passengers expect from an airline by introducing standard premium amenities and affordable flights. Now, we're extending this experience to the booking process, making it easy to immediately understand how much a flight costs by showing one number."
Air Transat, which flies to the Caribbean, Mexico, Europe and the Mediterranean, has traditionally included all-in fares for its flights and package holiday and advocated such pricing for years. "It's interesting to see the change of heart of those who just very recently saw the light," Transat spokeswoman Debbie Cabana wrote in an email. The advertising changes are coming after the Conservative government announced in December new rules that will require Canadian airlines to include all fees and taxes in their advertised prices.
The Canadian Transportation Agency is consulting various stakeholders before drafting new regulations. They will need to figure out how the rules can be crafted so Canadian airlines are not put at a disadvantage
MONTREAL — Canada's largest airlines have all launched all-inclusive pricing efforts that make it easier for passengers to determine the actual cost of flying. Air Canada began on Wednesday to advertise prices that show the final cost of a ticket by combining the extra charges that have been left out in the past. Porter Airlines, which flies regional planes mainly from its base at Toronto City Centre airport said it would begin to advertise the total cost of a flight on Friday.
They join WestJet Airlines (TSX:WJA) which began to advertise all-in fares in January.
The new pricing structure will factor in all of the fees, surcharges and taxes that customers wind up paying, which in some cases can virtually double the posted price of airline tickets.
The extra amounts include Nav Canada fees, airport improvement charges, fuel surcharges, insurance and air security charges.
Consumers also have to add taxes -- GST or Harmonized Sales Tax, and possibly sales tax or other taxes depending on the province or country. Canada's largest carrier (TSX:AC.B) launched its new all-in fare policy as it unveiled a seat sale marking its 75th anniversary. "Our all-in price advertising initiative is a response to our customers' increased desire for transparency and simplicity when shopping for air fares," said Air Canada marketing vice-president Craig Landry.
Air Canada's new all-in price will be displayed on its website, email specials, online and print advertising. Large newspaper ads on Wednesday, for example, showed a flight from Montreal to London costing $887, with the base fare starting at $244 and $643 in additional charges. Final prices may vary by routing and individual options such as baggage fees.
The changes come ahead of laws requiring more honest airfare ads expected later this year. Robert Kokonis, president of airline consulting firm AirTrav Inc., said the carriers didn't want to wait until the Christmas deadline. "I think they wanted to get it over with and also position themselves in front of the consumers' eyes as doing the right thing," he said in an interview. Calgary-based WestJet changed its print advertising in January, but bookings on its website and that of Air Canada don't at first glance show all-in prices.
"We are still working out some technical details to be able to display all-in pricing within our booking engine, which we expect will happen later this year," said spokesman Robert Palmer. Passengers initially see only the base fare when choosing flight times. But they can see the all-in price and breakdown of extra charges by clicking the price associated with individual flights. Unlike the other carriers, Porter will only show one price without highlighting fees and taxes separately, said president Robert Deluce. "We've been able to change what passengers expect from an airline by introducing standard premium amenities and affordable flights. Now, we're extending this experience to the booking process, making it easy to immediately understand how much a flight costs by showing one number."
Air Transat, which flies to the Caribbean, Mexico, Europe and the Mediterranean, has traditionally included all-in fares for its flights and package holiday and advocated such pricing for years. "It's interesting to see the change of heart of those who just very recently saw the light," Transat spokeswoman Debbie Cabana wrote in an email. The advertising changes are coming after the Conservative government announced in December new rules that will require Canadian airlines to include all fees and taxes in their advertised prices.
The Canadian Transportation Agency is consulting various stakeholders before drafting new regulations. They will need to figure out how the rules can be crafted so Canadian airlines are not put at a disadvantage
Tuesday, January 24, 2012
Pricing Club Conference (3rd Conference on Pricing Strategy & Management) Paris France, March 26th 2012.
"Price and Prejudice"Pricing is your product’s most important statement. Michael Hurwich - Managing Partner SPMG
Full Brochure:
To register:
http://www.pricing2win.com/Register.htm & pay on line or email Sally at sbrodie@youneedpricing.com to register and use other means of payment
Paris, March 26th 2012
The „French Pricing Club‟, the „Pricing & Value Strategies Club‟ (on LinkedIn), the Club
„Pricing & Valeur Client‟ (on Viadeo) and Strategic Pricing Management Group are
organising a conference on the theme "Price and Prejudice" in Paris on March 26th 2012.
The Conference "Price & Prejudice" aims to focus on the organizational prejudices that prevent
effective pricing practices in many organizations, but also on the psychological dimensions of
Pricing & value strategies. It will provide real life experience from professionals from the
business world but also frameworks, tools and theories developed by researchers and
consultants.
This event aims to uncover practical experience as well as the latest breakthroughs in research
& impact modeling under three major headings, which are: Pricing Image Management , Price
organization development and Pricing Psychology . This conference will look at how to overcome
pricing prejudices to develop an effective pricing organization, how to utilize pricing psychology
to your advantage and on how to manage your pricing image for competitive advantage.
Includes presentations from
Conference presided by:
- Gérard Fauconnet (ex-Manager Global Pricing, Schneider Electric + Passionate Pricer)
- Loïc Le Corre (Managing Director, SPMG + President Pricing Clubs)
Pricing Club ConferenceProgram Overview 9h00-9h30: Welcome coffee and registration
9h30-9h45: Opening address: Gérard Fauconnet (ex Schneider Electric & President
Pricing Club)
9h45–10h20: Keynote address: Bernard Demeure – Vice President + Head Retail Practice – Oliver
Wyman - "Managing your pricing image .. and the impact of Pricing on your image"
10h20-10h45 : Coffee Break
10h45 – 12h15: Plenary session: "Developing a Pricing culture – influences and prejudices"
- Theory + Practice Stéphane Liozu (Président & CEO of ARDEX Ame ricas)
- Pricing Image Management - Loïc Le Corre - Managing Director SPMG + Pricing Club
- Pricing Practices in Europe - Pol Vanaerde – President European Pricing Platform
12h15-13h45: Lunch
14h00-15h30 : Parallel Session 1 "Price Perception & Positioning"
- Practitioner; Sophie Heller - Director Marketing ING Direct
- Practitioner + Consultant: Vernon Lennon President – The Pricing Cloud
14h00-15h30 : Parallel Session 2 "Optimizing New Product Launch"
- Practitioner: Michel van den Berge - Director Innovation Agilent
- Tools: Alex Smith - Director PROS Pricing Solutions
14h00-15h30 : Parallel Session 3 "Brand Pricing & Image"
- Practitioner: Elizabeth Laisne –Former Global Pricing Director Lenovo
- Consultant: Alain Meloche – Managing Director SPMG:
15h30-15h55 : Coffee Break
15h55-17h25 : Parallel Session 1 "Selling a dream & Pricing it"
- Theory/Practice : Gilles Laurent , Professeur HEC: "Pricing Luxury Goods"
- Practitioner: Michael Hurwich – Managing Director SPMG:
15h55-17h25 : Parallel Session 2 "Pricing the priceless: Health"
- Practitioner: Enrique Dodero - Pricing Manager at GE Healthcare
- Consultant : Loïc Le Corre – Managing Director SPMG
15h55-17h25 : Parallel Session 3 "Creating a Pricing Culture & organization"
- Practitioner - Govert Spit - Global Pricing Director at Castrol - BP
- Tools/Practice: Daniel Rueda – President Open Pricer
17h25-17h40: Final wrap-up and concluding remarks:
Join the clubs (free membership):
„Pricing et Valeur Client‟ : http://www.viadeo.com/groups/?containerId=00227v6uwz4vbyhj
„Pricing & Value Strategies‟: http://www.linkedin.com/groups?mostPopular=&gid=127106
Pricing Club Conference
Registration for the conference Registration includes material, coffee breaks and lunch.
To register: http://www.pricing2win.com/Register.htm & pay on line or email Sally at sbrodie@youneedpricing.com to register and use other means of payment
Regular rate: 349 Euros (399 € after 28th February 2012)
Pricing Club Members: 249 Euros (299 € after 28th February 2012) (LinkedIn & Viadeo)
VenueThe Conference will be hosted at "La Maison des Polytechniciens", 12 rue de Poitiers, 75007
Paris.
Organising committee:
Gérard Fauconnet – Former „
Marketing Vice-President / Chief Pricing Officer Schneider Electric’
Loïc Le Corre – Managing Director SPMG Europe
Michael Hurwich –President SPMG
:
Full Brochure:
To register:
http://www.pricing2win.com/Register.htm & pay on line or email Sally at sbrodie@youneedpricing.com to register and use other means of payment
Paris, March 26th 2012
The „French Pricing Club‟, the „Pricing & Value Strategies Club‟ (on LinkedIn), the Club
„Pricing & Valeur Client‟ (on Viadeo) and Strategic Pricing Management Group are
organising a conference on the theme "Price and Prejudice" in Paris on March 26th 2012.
The Conference "Price & Prejudice" aims to focus on the organizational prejudices that prevent
effective pricing practices in many organizations, but also on the psychological dimensions of
Pricing & value strategies. It will provide real life experience from professionals from the
business world but also frameworks, tools and theories developed by researchers and
consultants.
This event aims to uncover practical experience as well as the latest breakthroughs in research
& impact modeling under three major headings, which are: Pricing Image Management , Price
organization development and Pricing Psychology . This conference will look at how to overcome
pricing prejudices to develop an effective pricing organization, how to utilize pricing psychology
to your advantage and on how to manage your pricing image for competitive advantage.
Includes presentations from
Conference presided by:
- Gérard Fauconnet (ex-Manager Global Pricing, Schneider Electric + Passionate Pricer)
- Loïc Le Corre (Managing Director, SPMG + President Pricing Clubs)
Pricing Club ConferenceProgram Overview 9h00-9h30: Welcome coffee and registration
9h30-9h45: Opening address: Gérard Fauconnet (ex Schneider Electric & President
Pricing Club)
9h45–10h20: Keynote address: Bernard Demeure – Vice President + Head Retail Practice – Oliver
Wyman - "Managing your pricing image .. and the impact of Pricing on your image"
10h20-10h45 : Coffee Break
10h45 – 12h15: Plenary session: "Developing a Pricing culture – influences and prejudices"
- Theory + Practice Stéphane Liozu (Président & CEO of ARDEX Ame ricas)
- Pricing Image Management - Loïc Le Corre - Managing Director SPMG + Pricing Club
- Pricing Practices in Europe - Pol Vanaerde – President European Pricing Platform
12h15-13h45: Lunch
14h00-15h30 : Parallel Session 1 "Price Perception & Positioning"
- Practitioner; Sophie Heller - Director Marketing ING Direct
- Practitioner + Consultant: Vernon Lennon President – The Pricing Cloud
14h00-15h30 : Parallel Session 2 "Optimizing New Product Launch"
- Practitioner: Michel van den Berge - Director Innovation Agilent
- Tools: Alex Smith - Director PROS Pricing Solutions
14h00-15h30 : Parallel Session 3 "Brand Pricing & Image"
- Practitioner: Elizabeth Laisne –Former Global Pricing Director Lenovo
- Consultant: Alain Meloche – Managing Director SPMG:
15h30-15h55 : Coffee Break
15h55-17h25 : Parallel Session 1 "Selling a dream & Pricing it"
- Theory/Practice : Gilles Laurent , Professeur HEC: "Pricing Luxury Goods"
- Practitioner: Michael Hurwich – Managing Director SPMG:
15h55-17h25 : Parallel Session 2 "Pricing the priceless: Health"
- Practitioner: Enrique Dodero - Pricing Manager at GE Healthcare
- Consultant : Loïc Le Corre – Managing Director SPMG
15h55-17h25 : Parallel Session 3 "Creating a Pricing Culture & organization"
- Practitioner - Govert Spit - Global Pricing Director at Castrol - BP
- Tools/Practice: Daniel Rueda – President Open Pricer
17h25-17h40: Final wrap-up and concluding remarks:
Join the clubs (free membership):
„Pricing et Valeur Client‟ : http://www.viadeo.com/groups/?containerId=00227v6uwz4vbyhj
„Pricing & Value Strategies‟: http://www.linkedin.com/groups?mostPopular=&gid=127106
Pricing Club Conference
Registration for the conference Registration includes material, coffee breaks and lunch.
To register: http://www.pricing2win.com/Register.htm & pay on line or email Sally at sbrodie@youneedpricing.com to register and use other means of payment
Regular rate: 349 Euros (399 € after 28th February 2012)
Pricing Club Members: 249 Euros (299 € after 28th February 2012) (LinkedIn & Viadeo)
VenueThe Conference will be hosted at "La Maison des Polytechniciens", 12 rue de Poitiers, 75007
Paris.
Organising committee:
Gérard Fauconnet – Former „
Marketing Vice-President / Chief Pricing Officer Schneider Electric’
Loïc Le Corre – Managing Director SPMG Europe
Michael Hurwich –President SPMG
:
Tuesday, January 17, 2012
How to Make Sure You Get the Price Your New Product Deserves
Article by Alain Meloche, Managing Partner at SPMG
Written for The Toronto Product Management Association
Written for The Toronto Product Management Association
Your
company’s President has approached you directly, saying that a new product is
being introduced and that it represents the future of the company as he expects
great growth potential from this initiative. As the Product Manager, he wants
you to find the right price that’s going to capture the value but provide an
incentive for the company to capture market quickly, as competitors are very
aggressive.
New
product pricing, given its sensitivity, highlights overall pricing issues and
so is valuable as an example of the issues that need to be considered in the
pricing of products. But overall, it is
also becoming a more significant issue for a growing number of firms as product
lifecycles shorten and the level of competition increases. As for all products,
but especially so for new products, the pricing of these products is especially
difficult as there are a number of different and sometimes conflicting, factors
at play. Internally, the finance department may want to ensure that development
and implementation costs are at least covered and ROI targets met while the
marketing group may want to maximize market acceptance and share. Externally,
customers may want the benefits that a product provides but may hold back if
they perceive risk associated, especially with a new product’s purchase.
How
do you balance these various factors and set a price for new products? Our
experience has led us to believe that resolving some basic questions provides a
roadmap to setting those prices.
1)
What
strategic objectives should those prices support?
2)
How
does the new product fit within the context of the existing product portfolio?
3)
What
benefits would customers receive from the product, actual and perceived?
4)
How
could the price level and structure be set to capture all the value offered
while taking into account customers’ costs and risks associated with new
product adoption and the competitive environment?
1) Strategic Objectives in Setting
Price
Whatever
the chief strategic concern for a new service or product, price should help
address it. This is true no matter what that concern is—whether to achieve
rapid penetration of the market, retain customers, or protect margins despite
uncertain costs. In each case, the strategy should be reflected in the price.
For
example, new long distance providers, with high fixed costs but low variable
costs and believing that customers were price sensitive, undercut prices of
existing suppliers in order to rapidly gain market share. Everyone is familiar
with regular price changes for gasoline based in part on gas companies passing
on their feedstock cost uncertainties into the marketplace. “Whole life”
insurance is priced highest for wage earners with young families and declines
as needs and ability to pay declines- retirees and those on fixed incomes-
thereby helping to retain customers for life.
The
product lifecycle is a useful framework for thinking about how corporate
objectives may change over time and these are shown in Figure 1. below.
Figure 1. Product Lifecycle and
Objectives for the product
Companies
using pricing strategies in support of those objectives, either explicitly or
implicitly balance price with the value provided by their offering as shown in
Figure 2.
Figure 2. Price/ Value and Pricing
Strategies
There are two basic strategies
available for new product release prices.
Premium
·
Demand is likely to be price
inelastic
·
There are buyers that have a
wide range of acceptable prices
·
Little is known about
production and/or marketing prices
Penetration
·
Demand is price elastic
·
Entry barriers are low
·
No separate price-market
segments that could accept a wide range of prices
·
Large sales volumes lead to
economies of scale
In turn, there are three key
elements that determine whether premium or penetration pricing should be used:
·
Nature of the product
o
Revolutionary
o
Evolutionary
o
Me-too
·
The potential competitive
response
·
The potential competitive
response
·
The existing product
portfolio and the resulting company position
The
value of new products typically increases directly proportionally to whether
the product is me-too, evolutionary, or revolutionary. This in turn, provides
guidance relative to the extent that penetration or premium pricing strategy
should be pursued. The newer or more revolutionary is the product, with the
fewer the comparables, the greater is the opportunity to seek premium pricing.
On the other hand, for products that may simply be new to your own company, but
not to the market, the opportunity for premium pricing is limited. Penetration
pricing is more realistic, but, given existing competitors and their
competitive responses, realistically, pricing should occur closer to the
price/value equivalency line. Opportunities for penetration pricing occur again
at the lower end, with low price/value where the competitive threat presented
may not warrant strong competitor response.
2) New product fit within the context of the existing
product portfolio
While
a new product may represent an entirely new niche or position for your company,
its position, to some extent will still be judged in terms of your existing
portfolio. Think of the Volkswagen
Phaeton. While it represented a completely different product from the
existing Golf, Jetta, and Passat lines,
the market still judged the new product in light of that existing product line.
It was difficult for customers to make the leap from the $15,000- $30,000 price
band into products that started at twice that level.
The
issue of cannibalization also affects release price. Let’s suppose that
Volkswagen had released the Phaeton
in the $35,000-$40,000 price range. While it would have been more consistent
with Volkswagen’s existing position,
the incremental $5,000-$10,000 price over the top end of the Passat may well
have led to significant cannibalization of Passat sales. After all, for that
relatively minor amount of money, buyers at that range, with somewhat less price sensitivity may have chosen a
clearly superior product. The question then became: would a buyer of a brand
such as Mercedes or BMW have been willing to switch given the value ascribed to
the Mercedes and BMW brands?
The
fatal error in VW’s perception was
its belief that only performance and other “hard” quality criteria were used by
customers to judge the value of the product. The result was a market that
perceived an overpriced product while VW was marketing based on the assumption
that market was prepared to accept a product in a substantially different
position from the rest of its portfolio due to a price/value offering better
than its competitors. The approach may have been valid had the market judged
value purely on the basis of engineering factors.
Conversely, BMW could choose
to launch a cheaper vehicle at a lower price point. While BMW internally, may
believe that by pricing to penetrate into a new market segment as shown in Figure 5, the market may perceive that BMW
market strategy is one of pricing generally above the value line so that the
quality of the new product may be suspect. The connotation in the market’s mind
may then bring the overall perception of BMW market position down the
value/price chart. So, it’s important to recognize that price makes a statement
about your product. While VW had wanted to make a statement about its”new” product quality, the market
viewed that statement as significantly inconsistent with the current position.
3) Actual and perceived benefits from a product
To understand how much of a
premium can be charged at the upper limit of the price line requires some
understanding of the benefits of the product. Again, this depends on several
factors, the most important of which are:
1)
The customer’s industry ( i.e. consumer, business,..)
2)
The product’s life stage: me-too, evolutionary, revolutionary
The degree to which these
can be measured with some degree of precision and the extent to which actual to
perceived benefits are balanced are represented in Figure 3. As can be seen
from that chart, the most readily measured benefits are related to those products
that are well established in the marketplace and sold on a B2B basis.
Revolutionary products sold to consumers are those the most likely to be sold
on the basis of perceived benefits.
Figure
3: Impact of the Nature of the product and the Customer’s market on Benefits
Focus
In the case of a B2B sale,
incremental benefits, however, can more easily be quantified through a value
chain analysis where the seller can make estimates as to benefits such as
supplies, H.R. resources that may be saved through purchase of the new product.
For B2C estimates of
the value added, perceptions of the benefits are more likely to lead decision
making.
4)
Setting Prices
There are two key elements in pricing be it for new or
existing products: level and structure.
Level
Release price sends an
important message to the market as seen in the automotive case discussed above.
Two approaches were highlighted in the automotive case and discussed
subsequently;
- Premium
- Penetration
For premium pricing,
the question is : what’s the upper limit? Three factors, in turn, are involved
in that answer:
1)
Incremental benefits (actual and perceived)
2)
Existing perceptions of the company in the marketpalce
3)
Actual and perceived costs and risks of the purchase by the
customer
For penetration pricing, the
question is: how low should you go?
1)
At the lower limit, consider cost-plus
2)
Competitive response is a critical factor since too low a
price will likely elicit strong competitor response.
3)
Market uptake (volume) needs to be balanced with the
potential margins that could be obtained by pricing closer to the benfits
actually provided by the product
Structure
Again, it’s critical that
the structure be designed so that corporate and customer objectives be
supported by the price structure. For example, 25 years ago, few vehicles were
leased while today, approximately 20% of vehicles are leased. Through this
pricing structure, price was effectively deconstructed, allowing for easier
purchases with less money upfront. Also, through the nature of that structure,
those leasing cars continue to outlay money to the manufacturers on an ongoing
bais as leases expire and consumers typically lease another vehicle.
Key Learnings
The
importance of new product pricing lies in its highlighting of issues that are
common to pricing generally. In this case, three key points stand out:
1)
Understand what customers will
be using to measure value (unlike the engineers at VW)
2)
Understand where your
product lies in the spectrum of new products:
a.
If it’s entirely new, with
no comparables then more pricing flexibility is possible
b.
For a product with better
performance characteristics than existing comparables, the magnitude of
incremental pricing can be more easily quantified as the measures/ metrics for
the benefits are clearer.
c.
If a product is only new to
your company, then pricing needs to be based on competitive factors.
3)
Quantify, quantify,
quantify- to the maximum extent possible: BUT, always take into account
the broader context and common sense!
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)





